First post in a longtime and I thought I would put down some views on the 2017 season for Hampshire now that there is a bit of daylight between the time of writing and the tense nerve wracking finish at Edgbaston.
I’m still not sure whether to put the 2017 season down as a success or failure? I guess somewhere in the middle is most accurate as Division One survival was achieved and a seventh Finals day appearance in eight seasons was also earned. That sounds not too bad but the fact is that survival should have been earned weeks before the last day in the Championship and another semi final defeat at our hoodoo ground Edgbaston meant the season will be remembered not as fondly as it could have been.
Let’s focus first on the Championship, it seemed as though we couldn’t go five minutes without being reminded that we were lucky to be in the First Division and the name Kolpakshire was never far away from our critics lips. Now I would certainly concede that Hampshire were lucky to be reprieved at the end of 2016 but the Kolpakshire jibe got really tiresome very quickly and was often used by people who’s own team had no shortage of their own non English qualified players. It was important in most Hampshire supporters minds that we showed the rest of the country that we deserved to be in the top tier as the wider cricketing public couldn’t wait for Hampshire to fail.
On Hampshire’s day they could mix it with every team in the division even runaway Champions Essex thanks to finding a settled bowling attack that had variety and posed a constant threat to opposition batsman. Unfortunately the batting could never quite match up to this and was shaky all season. Two early season wins were gained despite picking up no bonus batting points although one of the wins was achieved by chasing over 300 in the fourth innings. More often than not the batting was bailed out by the bowlers. Late season this help dried up and it very nearly cost Hampshire their top flight status.
Just 14 games in the Championship meant that batsmen getting to 1000 was going to be more difficult than it had been traditionally but nobody even got anywhere near. James Vince was the leading runscorer with 626 at an average of 32.94. It meant eyebrows were raised when he was picked to go to Australia but we all know James is better than this and hopefully his potential will be fulfilled this winter.
The other batsmen struggled for consistency and only 7 centuries were scored by Hampshire this year although there were 4 scores of 97-99 as well. Sadly we saw the farewell of Michael Carberry, resuming his career after treatment for cancer in April he got a ton against Cardiff MCCU and so nearly got a hundred vs Middlesex in the first home Championship game but that was as good as it got and when it was announced that he was leaving for Leicestershire I think most people felt the time was right. Michael has been one of my all time faves for Hampshire since arrival in 2006 and his red ball form in the late 2000s combined with his white ball form in 2012 and 2013 was always a joy to watch. I know I’m not the only person who felt he was hard done by England and I hope that his two years at Leics will be a success.
Rilee Rossouw goes down as a big disappointment, his arrival was exciting as it felt Hampshire were signing a quality batsman that would give some extra depth to Hampshire. There were concerns raised at the same time that signing him would prevent youth from getting a chance and were also the reasons why Hampshire were given the lazy Kolpakshire tag. Roussow made his highest score 99 when he was batting with a broken finger but struggled otherwise and even after a run of ducks he still continued to be selected. This disappointed me as it was counter productive to the team and did mean that youth was not given a chance as often as it should have been. Injuries curtailed his season and hopefully next year Rilee will have learnt more about English conditions and try to adapt to them.
Tom Alsop was the main victim of Roussow’s arrival, a breakthrough year in 2016 in a struggling side meant that Tom gained recognition with an England Lions tour. Scores on the tour were not prolific and combined with the arrival of Roussow meant he started the season out of the side. The 50 over cup gave him his chance and he took it with a ton at Canterbury but still often found himself making way. His return to the side ended up being due to an injury to Lewis McManus and he took the gloves towards the end of the season. His keeping certainly let nobody down but an average of just 16.85 meant that 2017 was a step back in his career.
George Bailey and Jimmy Adams showed glimpses of the form that was needed by Hampshire to sustain a title challenge, they made four of the seven centuries made by Hampshire. Bailey played just 10 championship matches scored 610 at 38 and would have almost certainly scored more than James Vince had he played as much. Bailey missed the first three games to get married and also missed a match in September to travel to Pakistan to be in a World XI T20 squad. He led the side well I thought including some good declarations but the Pakistan trip meant that people questioned his commitment and the decision to release him to travel to this when Hampshire’s safety was not yet secure.
It never quite got going for ever present Sean Ervine after his excellent late 2016 form. Two fifties and a Double Ton against Warwickshire were the best of his efforts and where Sean in the past used to get a lot of unfair criticism from supporters in my opinion they were starting to have a point.
Joe Weatherley with the arrival of Roussow was knocked down the pecking order and started his season on loan at Kent but injuries meant he was recalled and given an opportunity late season that he was unable to take. In addition it meant chances for Calvin Dickinson and Felix Organ. Too early to say for all three how they will go but they will need to make sure they grab with both hands any opportunities that come along.
A mention for Will Smith who left for a second spell with Durham, he spent the summer in the seconds and despite scoring heavily never featured in the Championship. I wish him well remembering him fondly for his last wicket partnership with James Tomlinson to help Hampshire win promotion in 2014. Will also proved a useful T20 bowler and captained the side in difficult circumstances in 2016.
Lewis McManus didn’t kick on from his breakthrough season in 2016, Just 285 runs at 23 from 10 matches was disappointing and whilst he didn’t do much wrong with the gloves I would say he won’t be certain to regain his place at the start of 2018.
Liam Dawson also struggled with the bat but I think perhaps wasn’t helped by moving around the order and that he was in and out of the side due to England commitments. The good news was that we saw his best season with the ball for some time and he bowled economically. 31 wickets at 26 was a great backup to the seamers. I am disappointed how it turned out with England for Liam as he is far better than the figures showed but the wider criticism certainly didn’t seem to affect him bowling wise.
Kyle Abbott was the undeniable player of the season. 60 wickets at 18.2 and the added bonus of 418 runs at 29 showed him to be worth every penny that it cost to take him away from international cricket. Abbott made things happen with the ball and Hampshire suddenly had the potency to cause all teams trouble. 7-41 up at Yorkshire to put Hampshire on the way to an unlikely victory as well as 6-20 ultimately in defeat vs Essex were special performances. Kyle was certainly no rabbit with the bat as he arrived in early 2017 with a first class average just below 17 but certainly showed us of his ability and in digging out Hampshire with the bat as well as the ball it certainly is no exaggeration to say that Hampshire would be heading back to Division 2 without him.
Now whilst Abbott was certainly the figurehead he didn’t go without support and by the end of the season Hampshire found a well balanced attack and left some supporters including me dreaming about what could have been if this attack had played together more or had some more back up from the batting department.
Gareth Berg bowled well with in partnership with Abbott and 37 wickets at 26 was great support to go with his 568 runs at 31. Importantly hitting the winning runs in a large chase in the season opener in Leeds and his 34 vs Warwickshire on the last day at Edgbaston helped use up valuable time to gain that 5 points from the draw that ensured survival. Nobody out there seems to enjoy playing for the club than Gareth and its a pleasure to watch his wholehearted efforts with bat and ball.
Fidel Edwards towards the end of the season came back to be the bowler we saw late in 2015 when he kept Hampshire up with his devastating slingy pace. Early season injury for the second successive year although this time luckily not season ending like 2016 meant he contributed 30 wickets at 25 . Cricket tragics like myself love a West Indian quick and as there isn’t much out there like him then I really hope we get to see a firing Edwards next year.
Ian Holland goes down as the find of the season for me. The US born Australian got a first team opportunity in the One day cup then subsequently the Championship took 19 wickets at 18 to go with 233 runs at 33. The highlight was with the pink ball against Somerset where he reduced the hosts from 102-1 to 110-5 with four quick wickets and added a runout shortly after. He conceded just 2.63 runs an over and was that effective fourth seamer that the county have traditionally not had.
I’m really not sure what to make of Mason Crane’s season mainly because it felt like we saw so little of him. Not selected in April due to conditions then spent time carrying drinks for England so just made 7 Championship appearances taking 16 wickets at 44. some pundits suggested he move counties to play every game but this seems unlikely that any county would pick him every game especially in April. You also have to question the value of him carrying drinks when he could have been getting overs under his belt with Hampshire especially if he is to be required in the test team this winter.
Also featured were Matt Salisbury previously of Essex who played in two games with minimal success and he was not seen again. Brad Taylor also got one game up at Old Trafford when Liam Dawson and Mason Crane were unavailable. Unfortunately he struggled and as a result did not come close to selection again. He is spending some of the winter in New Zealand to help his development and shows there still is a future for him at the club.
Brad Wheal and Reece Topley had injury hit summers playing four and two games respectively. Reece did at least get to bowl this summer and played more games than last year but that will be little consolation to him as his season was ended with a stress fracture of the back for the second successive year. Both bowlers will be useful next year and I hope that they can both overcome injuries as Hampshire are assembling a title winning unit.
Frustration that it nearly ended in tears for Hampshire on the last day. In early August Hampshire played Lancashire when thoughts were definitely about looking up the table. It would have been a travesty if Hampshire had gone down as they only spent about four hours of the season in the bottom two but those nearly were the wrong few hours to be in the relegation zone. There were plenty of highs and plenty of lows often within sessions of each other. Bowling Champions Essex out for 76 then being bowled out for the same score two days later to lose after enforcing the follow on the best example of highs to lows.
The problems are obvious in that the batting just doesn’t back up the bowling often enough. However the solutions are a lot harder to identify, Hampshire were not the only county to struggle with batting in 2017. A glance at the Div 1 averages or the fact that England have been unable to find a settled batting lineup tells you a lot about the state of batting in county cricket at present. Hampshire do need to strengthen this area but from where is not at all obvious. Overseas players unless you can get a Sangakarra might not help often due to availability as much as anything. Kolpaks can work but again its an unpopular step and as with Roussow no guarantee of success. Signing from other counties is also not necessarily a good plan given how other counties are also struggling with batting. The youth route also has issues in the modern game, are the players there ready or good enough and once players are selected can you afford to give them enough games if they don’t hit the ground running straight away?
Its a tough one and I’m glad I’m not in Giles or Craig White’s position as there are some very difficult decisions to be made this winter regarding the batting. I am relieved we survived for another year and the bowling excites me that we will spend the 2018 season looking up rather than down and we show the rest of the public that we deserve to be in the first on merit.